Category Archives: news

General Synod of the Bible Presbyterian Church

The 70th General Synod of the Bible Presbyterian Church convened yesterday in Grand Island, NY, and will continue until August 8th.  The theme is “The Foundation: Jesus Christ – If the foundations be destroyed.”  The docket lists the preaching at each worship service being on a foundational principle:  “Building on the Foundation,” “Revelation of the Foundation,” “Incarnation and Virgin Birth,” “The Resurrection of Christ,” “The Deity of Christ,” “The Atonement,” “The Conquest by the Foundation.”  In addition there is one more message and two seminars on American Presbyterianism.  The message is “The Father of American Presbyterianism:  Francis Makemie.”  The seminars are “Progression of American Presbyterianism – 1706-1806, 1806-1906, 1906-2006,” and “The demise of the mainline presbyterian church, the rise of the Bible Presbyterian Church, and the future.”

The rest of the docket looks pretty straight-forward.  There is a report on their web site.  I’ll post again when I hear anything more about this General Synod or leave a comment if you know anything.

You can check out the denomination’s General Synod Page.

GA of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church

In the midst of the PC(USA) GA news binge I sort of lost track of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church and Cumberland Presbyterian Church in America GA’s going on at the same time and place.  There were a couple of joint events and combined worship but I’ll focus on business from their Summary of Actions.

The 176th General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church convened June 19-23 in Brimingham, AL.  One of the interesting things about their organization is that in addition to a stated clerk they also have an engrossing clerk.  From the operations manual it appears that this individual only serves during the assembly and  the primary duty is to serve as the clerk-pro-tem in the stated clerk’s absence.  It was not clear if this was also the individual who dealt with preparing and processing “legislation” as an engrossing clerk would do in some state governments.

Much of the high profile business seemed to be related to the sale of the current headquarters and the capital campaign for the new headquarters.  You can check the status of the campaign at ilovemychurch.net.  Along with this there will be study, with a consultant, of the denominational structure.

One of the more interesting items of business is the adoption of a new logo.  At first glance I thought it was kind of mundane, but once I read the description and saw the combined elements it made sense.  I must admit however that the ordinary person, without the benefit of the description, will miss all the built-in symbolism.  Here is the information copied from their minutes:

GA of the Presbyterian Church in Canada

The 132nd GA of the Presbyterian Church in Canada was held in St. Catharines June 4-9, 2006.  As noted in an earlier post one of the notable events was the naming (their term) of Wilma Welsh as moderator, the first layperson to serve in that position. 

   The next day there was a recommendation by the “Clerks of Assembly” to not allow ruling elders as interim moderators of churches.  From the GA report it seems that it was not just to moderate session, like elders serving on, or who have served on COM, can do in the PC(USA), but rather to serve in an interim pastoral capacity.  This would be equivilant to a commissioned lay pastor in the PC(USA) even possibly being authorized to administer the sacraments.

   The daily report talks about a “lengthy discussion” about providing sanctuary.  The GA adopted the following:

“Should a congregation of The Presbyterian Church in Canada, desiring in obedience to God’s word and its own conscience, may offer sanctuary to an asylum seeker whose claim for refugee status has been rejected and who faces a risk of persecution if returned to his/her country of origin, they may consider the following as appropriate steps to follow:
1. have an independent review of the evidence provided by the asylum seeker that confirms the risk
2. have exhausted all of the legal and political recourses as outlined in this statement;
3. have followed the decision making procedures of The Presbyterian Church in Canada.”

   Much of the debate seems not to be about polity issues that seem to be the focus of denominations like the PC(USA) but about church and society issues like aids and sustainable development.  In the coming year there will be a focus on global health and the concern about getting affordable medication to developing countries will be brought up with the Canadian Government and corporations.

   Short notes:  The GA was introduced to an annual theme for the church “Year of Sabbath” which will be launched church-wide in Advent.  During the Year of Sabbath each congregation will be encouraged to participate in at least one weekend long spiritual retreat.  The GA celebrated the 40th anniversary of the ordination of women to both the office of teaching elder and ruling elder.  The moderator, Wilma Welsh, ordained in 1967, was one of the first women ordained.

For more information, reports, presentations, and pictures you can go to the PCC General Assembly Page

GA of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church

Greetings,

   The 73rd GA of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church met at Trinity Christian College in Illinois from June 21-28, 2006.  The denominations reports can be found on their web site’s GA page.

   One of the big items was the acceptance of a report on Justification.  The report is also available on the web site.  They report that a list of topics was included for examination of candidates.  There was also not much debate on the content, but how to distribute the report.

   I found it interesting that Book of Discipline amendments sent to the presbyteries by last year’s GA while approved will not go into affect until 2010!  Got to find out the story and history behind that one.

   The statistician’s report noted that their total membership has remained fairly constant at about 28,000 over the last few years but they lost three congregations to the PCA.

   Based on an overture from the Presbytery of Souther California a three member committee was formed “to study the issue regarding the propriety of the reception of illegal aliens into membership in the OPC…”

   There was also debate on two overtures requesting a new Psalter hymnal and the assembly finally adopted a substantially similar motion:

That the 73rd General Assembly of the Orthodox Presbyterian
Church authorize its Committee on Christian Education to seek to
develop a Psalter-Hymnal by 2011 (our 75th anniversary)—which includes
musical settings of all 150 Psalms, in their entirety, with as much
accuracy and as little archaic language and confusing syntax as
possible—for use in our congregations; that it authorize the Committee
on Christian Education to appoint a special Psalter-Hymnal committee;
and that it grant this special committee a budget of up to $5,000 [per
year for committee expenses].

   There is a revision to the Directory for Public Worship underway.  The amount of input from around the church was great enough that the process was extended a year to deal with all the comments.

   The ecumenical greetings included one from the Bible Presbyterian Church, a notable event since it is really the first official contact between the denominations since their split in 1937.

New York Times Ad

Greetings,
   I had initially read over this news item and decided that it was a bit far from GA to blog it but after seeing the press it was getting and that the PC(USA) news service issued a press release about it I changed my mind.  (Yes I hopped on the band wagon.)

   A week ago today on July 25 full page advertisements ran in the New York Times, and 50 other newspapers, supporting same-sex marriages and announcing continuation of the fight to legalize them.  This of course follows a recent string of court decisions against the practice.  Among the signers of the advertisement were eleven “religious leaders” including the moderator of the 213th GA of the PC(USA), the Rev. Jack Rogers.

For more:  The PC(USA) news service release

Latest case in the PC(USA) ordination standards debate – Mission Presbytery

Greetings,

    I am trying to verify this news via “official sources” but I noticed today on the blog “A Classical Presbyterian” that another PJC case will be heard regarding ordination standards and examination for candidacy in Mission Presbytery.  Whether this will end up being a “test case” for the new authoritative interpretation will have to be seen since the presbytery meeting where the disputed action occurred was in October 2005.  According to the blog the presbytery, in a very heated and unruly debate (what happened to “decently and in order”) admitted to candidacy a woman who is a “self-affirming practicing homosexual.”  I encourage you to read the comments on “A Classical Presbyterian” posted today (July 31).  I will see if any “standard” news sources pick this up.

Switching from news to commentary…
Test case?  I’m not sure this will end up being that but it will be interesting to see if the new AI does play into this.  I think the date being pre-GA 217 and the fact that it is an argument over being admitted to candidacy will make this case a bit different.  I know that in a similar situation in my presbytery a few years ago that the presbytery did not view this as a test of G6.0106b or G6.0108 since the advancement to candidacy did not involve ordination.  The general feeing among people in that debate seemed to be “we will approve it, this is not ordination, we will approve candidacy so that the individual can continue to work out their sense of call, but if this examination were for ordination the answer would be no.”

Trial by the Synod PJC is set for Sept. 9th.  Stay tuned.

Action of the Presbytery of Mississippi

Greetings,

   This is going to be a bit long but I have not found a good permanent link to this yet so I will reproduce it here.  I have seen it in the minutes of the presbytery, from which I extracted this, but it takes some reading of the minutes of presbytery to find it. (I know, if you are truly a GA Junkie, presbytery minutes are bed time reading material so go for it.)  It is also on a news flash page of the Presbyterian Forum, but from the naming of the page I don’t know if it will be persistent. 

   Therefore, I give you below, in its entirety, extracted from the minutes of the Presbytery of Mississippi Called Presbytery Meeting of July 13, 2006, the first official action by a presbytery reacting to the PUP report that I am aware of.  Several amendments were proposed, none approved.  The motion was approved but the vote was not recorded.  One dissent was recorded.

The Presbytery of Mississippi does hereby,

Declare that the action of the 217th General Assembly
in the passage of Recommendation 5 of the Peace, Unity, and Purity Task Force
Report, is a grievous error seriously lacking Biblical, Confessional and
Constitutional integrity, and of such magnitude that it places the Presbyterian
Church (U.S.A.) in a state of constitutional crisis, requiring that the
Presbytery of Mississippi re-evaluate the nature of its relationship with the
General Assembly,

Reaffirm its strong conviction that all constitutional
requirements for ordination, including G-6.0106b, are binding on all the
sessions and presbyteries of the Presbyterian Church, (U.S.A.), and none are
subject to being considered “inessential” by any governing body of
the Church,

Reaffirm its resolution that no exceptions to the requirement that
all deacons, elders and ministers must “live either in fidelity within the
covenant of marriage between a man and a woman or in chastity in
singleness” will be allowed within the jurisdiction of this Presbytery,
and

Resolve that any governing body of the Presbyterian Church,
(U.S.A.) which abrogates this requirement has broken fellowship with the
Presbytery of Mississippi. Ministers from such unbiblical, unconfessional, and
unconstitutional presbyteries will not be received for membership in this presbytery
unless they personally affirm their belief in and their willingness to be
governed by this requirement.

Rationale

Interaction between the governing bodies of the Presbyterian
Church should be marked by mutual trust. That trust is simply not possible when
the highest governing body commits egregious Biblical and Constitutional error
and when some presbyteries are openly and flagrantly in violation of Biblical,
Confessional, and Constitutional standards. The Presbytery of Mississippi, in
seeking to be faithful to the Bible, the Confessions of the Church, and the
Constitution as lawfully approved by the presbyteries of the Church, cannot
therefore stand in full fellowship with officers engaging in unconstitutional
and unbiblical behavior, or with governing bodies which bless such behavior.

At the same time, we understand that within unfaithful governing
bodies there are many ruling and teaching elders who seek to be faithful to the
Biblical, Confessional and Constitutional standards of the Church. We welcome
such faithful elders and ministers of the Word and Sacrament into our
membership. But because of the unfaithfulness of their sessions and
presbyteries, we must examine them with rigor similar to that which is required
for ministers received from other denominations.

The action of the 217th General
Assembly, in passing Recommendation 5 of the PUP Task Force report jeopardizes
the role that Scripture and the Constitution play in the governance of the
church, thus the constitutional crisis. As we grieve over this devastating
action, we pray for God’s mercy and guidance as the Presbytery of Mississippi
discerns the nature of faithfulness in this post-pup context.

B.   appoint a task
force, consisting of presbytery’s commissioners to the last four meetings of
General Assembly (2002, 2003, 2004, and 2006) with Dr. Emett Barfield as
moderator, charging this task force with the responsibility to examine
carefully the implications of the current crisis on the future of and the
ministry of this presbytery and to report its recommendations at the October
2006 meeting of presbytery.

PC(USA) OGA Advice on the PUP report

Greetings,

   The Office of the General Assembly (OGA) of the PC(USA) has issued two new advisory opinions (18 & 19) related to the PUP report as well as a less formal document referred to as constitutional musings.  There has been a response to the Advisory Opinion #18 from some church leaders on the conservative side.  Here are all the links:

Advisory Opinion 18 – Discernment in Examining Bodies – G6.0108 (PDF)
Response posted on the Presbyterian Coalition Web Site:  Flawed Advisory Opinion #18 Frustrates the Church (Web Page)

Advisory Opinion 19 – Implementing the Trust Clause for the Unity of the Church (Web Page)

Constitutional Musings #11 – Examining Officers (PDF)

New Wineskins Gathering

Has it really been three weeks since I have posted.  Sorry about
that.  I have a bunch of stuff to get caught up on.  I’ll try
to get it put up here in the next few days.

The breaking news it the New Wineskins Initiative Gathering in Tulsa
that concluded last night.  They are forming into the New
Wineskins Association of Churches.  In terms of moving forward in
light of recent PC(USA) actions they have adopted a “Congregational
Action Plan” that outlines a six month period of discernment. 
There are nine points to the Congregational Action Plan as well as a
five point “New Wineskins Initiative Action Plan.”  There is a
posting on their home page that appears to be a preliminary report.